Friday, July 1, 2011

Writing useful JavaScript applications in less than half the size of jQuery

Not too long ago, I tried to bring attention to how little of the jQuery library many developers actually use and argue that frontend developers should consider what sort of improvements their users would see if they could compile their code with the Advanced mode of the Closure Compiler. Today I would like to further that argument by taking a look at TargetAlert, my browser extension that I re-released this week for Chrome.

TargetAlert is built using Closure and plovr using the template I created for developing a Chrome extension. The packaged version of the extension includes three JavaScript files:

Name Size (bytes) Description
targetalert.js 19475 content script that runs on every page
options.js 19569 logic for the TargetAlert options page
targetalert.js 3590 background page that channels information from the options to the content script
Total 42634  

By comparison, the minified version of jQuery 1.6 is 91342 bytes, which is more than twice the size of the code for TargetAlert. (The gzipped sizes are 14488 vs. 31953, so the relative sizes are the same, even when gzipped.)

And to put things in perspective, here is the set of goog.require() statements that appear in TargetAlert code, which reflects the extent of its dependencies:
goog.require('goog.array');
goog.require('goog.dispose');
goog.require('goog.dom');
goog.require('goog.dom.NodeIterator');
goog.require('goog.dom.NodeType');
goog.require('goog.dom.TagName');
goog.require('goog.events');
goog.require('goog.events.EventType');
goog.require('goog.string');
goog.require('goog.ui.Component');
goog.require('goog.Uri');
goog.require('soy');
I include this to demonstrate that there was no effort to re-implement parts of the Closure Library in order to save bytes. On the contrary, one of the primary reasons to use Closure is that you can write code in a natural, more readable way (which may be slightly more verbose), and make the Compiler responsible for minification. Although competitions like JS1K are fun and I'm amazed to see how small JS can get when it is hand-optimized, even the first winner of JS1K, Marijn Haverbeke, admits, "In terms of productivity, this is an awful way of coding."

When deploying a packaged browser extension, there are no caching benefits to consider: if your extension includes a copy of jQuery, then it adds an extra 30K to the user's download, even when gzipped. To avoid this, your extension could reference https://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/1.6.1/jquery.min.js (or equivalent) from its code, but then it may not work when offline. Bear in mind that in some parts of the world (including the US! think about data plans for tablets), users have quotas for how much data they download, so you're helping them save a little money if you can package your resources more efficiently.

Further, if your browser extension has a content script that runs on every page, keeping your JS small reduces the amount of code that will be executed on every page load, minimizing the impact of your extension on the user's browsing experience. As users may have many extensions installed, if everyone starts including an extra 30K of JS, then this additional tax can really start to add up! Maybe it's time you gave Closure a good look, if you haven't already.

Want to learn more about Closure? Pick up a copy of my new book, Closure: The Definitive Guide (O'Reilly), and learn how to build sophisticated web applications like Gmail and Google Maps!

29 comments:

  1. Man, I really dig the intent of your post, but Closure is just so painful to code in. The beauty of jQuery is in its simplicity and eloquence, without sacrificing power. Closure feels so much like Java, YUI and other unnecessarily verbose APIs.

    Particularly since this is an extension -- making caching irrelevant -- did you ever consider using jQuery, but compiling the entire app w/ Closure Compiler to reduce the amount of jQuery that gets included?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Devil's advocate: I wonder what percentage of machines have jQuery in their browser cache. JQuery *is* needlessly huge, and lots of it could be compiled away, but then I'd have to redownload all the common internals that every page uses.

    ReplyDelete
  3. @Jason: I'm guessing the cache is irrelevant for most apps, unless they all share the exact same version, from the *same URL*. Even then you have parse time to consider, which on mobile can add up quickly (easily a few hundred ms in this case).

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm wondering why Chrome or other browsers don't support jQuery so that whenever there is a script loading jQuery or jQuery UI (and it's css templates) from:

    http://code.google.com/apis/libraries/devguide.html#jquery

    It will just use the browser's local files.

    This way, all this Closure discussions can be avoided.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Akishore: You cannot just "compile jQuery in Advanced mode" as jQuery is implemented today. Two things that I am considering are (1) creating an alternative implementation of jQuery that is Closure Compiler friendly, or (2) creating an option for Coffeescript so it generates Closure-style JavaScript that can be compiled in Advanced mode. I'm much more interested in the latter, but would consider taking on the former as contracting work.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Felix: The focus should not be on jQuery, but on how browsers manage resources, in general. For the Google-hosted JS libraries, they should be served with the correct cache headers so that things basically work as you describe (when the browser sees the URL, it retrieves the file from the cache and never goes to the server).

    However, there are two problems with this solution. The first is that some sites do not want to depend on Google as a CDN and would rather use their own. Unfortunately, I don't believe there's a way in HTML/JS to say, "Here is a list of URLs to a specific version jQuery: just load the first one that you have in your cache. If none are in cache, then just fetch the first one in the list." If such an API existed, you could easily use Google as your primary CDN but still use your own CDN as a backup.

    The second problem is that you are ignoring parse/execution time which increases the size of the library. Even if you can always pull jQuery out of the cache when you need it, it still has to be parsed (though the parse tree could also be cached) and executed for each page that uses it. Therefore, as you increase the size of the library, you take more of the user's time.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Jason/joel: Here is some good evidence that many users should have some version of jQuery (that is hosted by Google) cached in their browser:

    http://www.naveen.com.au/javascript/jquery/reason-why-i-let-google-host-jquery-for-me/486

    However, as the author notes, sites do use different versions of jQuery, which means they fetch different URLs, which eliminates any benefit from caching.

    As I noted in my response to Felix, it's also important to consider the additional execution time that results from loading a larger JS library, even if it is cached.

    ReplyDelete
  8. You are really a talented person such a informative and helpful content you provided with us.
    office.com/setup
    Your information on Java script really appreciated my all problems are solved...Thanks so much sharing a great setup.. keep shine and Rise...

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. That's amazing and interesting to write "JavaScript applications in less than half the size of jQuery".
    office.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  11. The post is good of how to write java script application, firstly we can start & check if it works good, then we accordingly start & the procedure is mentioned easily.

    office.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  12. Exhibitors can interact face-to-face with leads that wander past their booths and scan their badges to collect their information but lead gen happens very differently in a virtual environment. motivational speaker bio example and sample bio for speaker

    ReplyDelete
  13. ij.start canon is the manufacturer site to download Canon printer drivers. Install and set up Canon Printer from ij.start.canon | canon.com/ijsetup | cannon/ijsetup | Cox High-Speed Internet provides its users with COX Communications..Cox webmail Login

    ReplyDelete
  14. https://www.8deynews.com/567077/ While this may not be an ideal phone, it may have some limitations in terms of screen quality and camera quality, but it offers better specs than similarly priced phones like the Xiaomi Mi 10T Lit.

    ReplyDelete
  15. To access the Belkin router login interface, you will need the Belkin router, access to the network, and a web browser. You can access the network through a LAN cable or with your Wi-Fi connection. You will also have a connecting device such as a computer, phone, or tablet with a web browser on it to access the login page.

    ReplyDelete
  16. To rank your website top on the search engine, hire an SEO company in Gurgaon and get the best services at an affordable price. Being a reliable SEO agency in Gurugram we understand the need of our customers.
    SEO company in Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  17. This is definitely one of the best Articles till now. No wonder why people are liking your blog but now I can say This is the best article I have ever read. Thank you so much for sharing this article with us. 쇼미더벳 토토사이트, 쇼미더벳, 쇼미더벳 카지노사이트, 쇼미더벳 파워볼사이트, 쇼미더벳 회원가입코드, 쇼미더벳 슬롯머신

    ReplyDelete
  18. If you are pregnant and you ask how to travel during pregnancy? You should https://7ganj.ir/%da%86%da%af%d9%88%d9%86%d9%87-%d8%af%d8%b1-%d8%a8%d8%a7%d8%b1%d8%af%d8%a7%d8%b1%db%8c-%d8%b3%d9%81%d8%b1-%da%a9%d9%86%db%8c%d9%85%d8%9f/ read this article to the end. Pregnancy is an amazing, exciting, worrying and challenging time to plan and take action to make the necessary changes to your life during pregnancy

    ReplyDelete
  19. Each of your mental powers can be strengthened, and for each of these powers there is a game board. So maybe it is better to experience board games along with computer and mobile games. Where to buy game boards? Every purchase needs reviews. For example, to buy fruit, should you check that the fruits are healthy? Or does the fruit seller sell quality fruits? Is the price of fruit reasonable? However, in a face-to-face purchase, these reviews are not very difficult. But when shopping online, you should make sure that in addition to the right price and quality, you receive after-sales service and quality guarantee. Quality guarantee means that if the quality of the goods is not equal to the declared quality, the goods will be taken back or replaced. Unfortunately, these days, few stores go under the burden of quality assurance and stick the label "goods sold will not be returned" after the goods are sold. But how do we know if the quality of a product is high or the second-hand and fake material is offered? Commodity prices are the best measure. If the price of a product was too low and too discounted compared to other stores, you should know that there is no doubt that a pebble has fallen in the shoe. No one rubs fire! Definitely the item offered was less valuable and the price was lower.
    https://vitrinou.ir/reportage/57-%D8%A8%D8%B1%D8%AF%DA%AF%DB%8C%D9%85

    ReplyDelete
  20. Several factors matter when you choose the Microsoft 365 subscription. Depending on your requirements on the respective productivity platforms, these products are different in price. MS 365 is a cloud-based subscription productivity suite best suitable for individuals, businesses, and homes as users don’t have to worry about updates or any custom-related features
    microsoft365.com/setup
    Microsoft365.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  21. https://bit.ly/30b2MeI Those with a demo redness usually enjoys the limb. These categories of people have red and white skin with thick hair. For this category, balanced air is very pleasant, but they also have cold tolerance. They are brave and bold humans that come easily from the leadership of each group.

    ReplyDelete
  22. The first great thing about digital currencies is https://isiarticles.com/blog/143 that they are decentralized. This means that these digital currencies do not depend on any organization, organ or country, and this is what makes them popular all over the world. When you put your money in the bank, the manager of the same bank, the central branch of the bank you want, the central bank, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Top-Rated Food Processor at an Affordable Price in India
    From blending ingredients to kneading dough, food processors are quite useful in your kitchen. To purchase the best food processor KENSTAR is the correct choice.
    food processors

    ReplyDelete
  24. Best Accommodation and Home Stay in Tirthan Valley at Reasonable Price

    If you are looking for a furnished and reputed Homestay in Tirthan Valley you are at the right place. For a comfortable journey, you can stay here and enjoy your trip.

    Homestay in Tirthan

    https://www.tirthanvalley.net/home-stay-in-tirthan-valley

    ReplyDelete
  25. https://www.engko.in/site-office
    Site Office Manufacturer in Delhi | Prefab Construction Site Office
    Buy from the best Site Office manufacturer in Delhi for construction locations. Engko the top notch Prefab Site Office supplier with portability, durability for temporary uses.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Want to know where you can watch Movies, Tv series, or web series for free in 2021? FMovies - is the best platform to watch and download movies over the web. You can find all the latest Hollywood, Hollywood Dubbed Movies on FMovies Bollywood, and other movies on this site. It offers you to watch all the movies in high quality without paying a single penny. You also don’t have to go through any sign-up procedure to watch movies on Fmovies.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Great blog! Thanks for your excellent post and it was really helpful for me. Good work keep doing!
    Abogado De Divorcio En Virginia
    Abogado De Trafico En Virginia

    ReplyDelete